When you step into Grace Pizza & Shakes in Papillion, it’s clear you’re not just entering a pizza joint. You’re walking into a place where history and innovation dance on the same floor, where flavors hit you in ways you didn’t expect, and where every corner of the building tells a story. Yeah, it’s pizza—but it’s also something much bigger. It’s about community. It’s about preserving a piece of Papillion’s past while feeding its future. And honestly, that’s something worth celebrating.
We’ve seen restaurants come and go over the last 12 years, but when Grace Pizza opened its doors this week, it felt different. Maybe it’s the historic courthouse from 1875 that houses this new spot, or maybe it’s the buzz you feel when you walk down Jefferson Street, knowing you’re about to experience something special. Either way, Grace Pizza & Shakes just raised the bar in Sarpy County’s growing food scene.
A Historic Revival Meets Modern Vibes
Here’s the thing—Grace Pizza & Shakes isn’t just occupying any old building. It’s set up shop in the original courthouse of Papillion, a structure that’s stood tall since 1875. This isn’t just a pizza spot; this is a resurrection. The contrast between the historic shell and the modern design inside hits you in all the right ways. As Mayor David Black pointed out, the restoration of this building is a big win for the city, keeping that old-school charm while breathing new life into downtown Papillion.
Restoration of this building is a big win for the city, keeping that old-school charm while breathing new life into downtown Papillion. ~ Mayor David Black
Walking through the doors feels like stepping into a time capsule, but instead of mothballs and dust, you’re greeted by the smell of wood-fired pizza and the gleam of modern fixtures. The blend of history and contemporary style feels like they nailed it.
Ashley Weaver, a Papillion local, said it best: "I’ve been waiting for this to open for so long!" This spot is more than just a place to grab a meal—it’s a part of Papillion’s soul, reborn.
Grace Pizza: A Menu Built on Craft and Community
Now, let’s talk about what matters—the food. Joe Gomez, one of the co-owners, made it clear: they didn’t cut any corners getting this place ready. And it shows. The menu? A culinary playground for the whole family. We’re talking craft pizzas, towering shakes, and even some throwbacks to Grazia, their sister restaurant. It’s all about local ingredients and bold flavors here.
Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pepperoni or feeling adventurous with toppings you never thought belonged on a pizza, Grace delivers. And the shakes? We’re not talking your average milkshake. Think decadent, over-the-top creations like s’mores or cannoli shakes. Yeah, they’re indulgent, but isn’t that the point? You come to Grace to enjoy yourself, to let loose a little.
Mary Krause, from Omaha Food Magazine, put it perfectly: “Grace Pizza isn’t just feeding Papillion, it’s giving the community a place to come together, a space that honors the past while celebrating the future. And the food? It’s the kind of stuff that brings people back again and again.”
Thankful and Ready for More
We had a quick chat with Joe Gomez—he’s one of those guys you can’t help but like. Humble, excited, and clearly passionate about what they’re building here. He’s grateful for the community’s support, saying, “Thank you all for believing in our vision!” And it’s that vision that’s going to make Grace Pizza more than just a restaurant—it’s going to be a cornerstone of Papillion.
Community Spirit: A Pizza Joint with Heart
Let’s be real—there’s no shortage of pizza joints in Nebraska. But what sets Grace Pizza apart is the way they’re embedding themselves in the local community. Before they even opened, they were out delivering pizzas to nearby schools and businesses, making connections, building relationships. It’s not just about profit here—it’s about people.
Joseph Kenney, President of 316 Strategy Group, has been closely following this exciting project since November and has been on-site during the construction phase on several occasions, and sees the same potential: “This is more than a restaurant. Grace Pizza & Shakes is going to be a gathering place for the community.”
And that’s the real hook here. It’s not just about what you’re eating, it’s about the experience you’re having. The founder, Adrian Hembree, and partner Joe Gomez, get that. They’ve worked to ensure Grace is a place where everyone—from families to foodies—can feel at home.
Crafting a New Chapter in Papillion’s Culinary Story
Papillion is no stranger to good food, but Grace Pizza & Shakes is a fresh chapter. The city’s food scene has been quietly evolving, with spots like Sauced by Alfaro and Papillion Taco Guy laying down roots and building a loyal following. But Grace is adding a new flavor, something a little more… let’s call it ambitious.
As Sarpy Foodie pointed out, Grace joins nearly 200 restaurants in Sarpy County, but it’s not just another name on the list. This place is set to make waves. Whether you're a local looking for a new hangout or just passing through, this is the kind of place that makes you want to stop and stay a while.
A Space That Brings People Together
What we love most about Grace Pizza & Shakes is the energy. The building itself is alive, buzzing with history and modernity. But the team behind it? They’re the real pulse. They’ve created something that feels special—a restaurant, sure, but also a community space. A place where you can grab a slice and a shake and feel like you’re part of something bigger.
FAQs About Grace Pizza & Shakes
What is Grace Pizza & Shakes Papillion known for?
Grace Pizza & Shakes Papillion is known for its craft pizzas, over-the-top milkshakes, and its unique location in a historic courthouse building.
What kind of food does Grace Pizza serve?
Grace offers a variety of pizzas made with locally sourced ingredients, along with signature shakes and items like homemade pasta and artisan sandwiches.
Is Grace Pizza & Shakes kid-friendly?
Absolutely. The vibrant, fun atmosphere is designed for families, making it a great spot for kids and adults alike.
How does Grace Pizza contribute to the Papillion community?
Beyond serving food, Grace Pizza has been actively involved in the community, delivering pizzas to schools and businesses before even opening. They also plan to create up to 40 jobs locally.
Where is Grace Pizza located?
Grace Pizza is located in the historic downtown Papillion, inside the original county courthouse at 136 N. Jefferson St.
