Main Street Cellar owners Chuck and Deb Olson spent three years saving the old Bella Vita building. The first of its two restaurants is open, with Au Courant's Ben Maides in the kitchen, and the second arrives next month.
ELKHORN — For nearly three years, the most recognizable storefront in Olde Towne Elkhorn sat dark. Thursday afternoon, with Main Street merchants, a city council member, Omaha Food Magazine, and the Greater Omaha Chamber looking on, Chuck Olson cut the ribbon on 2620 N. Main St. and the building that housed Bella Vita Ristorante for 16 years officially became La Vita Nuova — Italian for "the new life."
Olson, who with his wife Deb owns Main Street Cellar a block south, bought the vacant building after Bella Vita's owner retired in 2023. He told the crowd the decision was never really about a restaurant. "Deb and I decided this building from 1897 needs to stay around," he said. The way to keep it, they concluded, was to renovate it into two restaurants: one open now, and a second upstairs that will open in about a month.

"The downtown area is something special, and it needs to be protected," Olson said. "This building needed to be protected."
Saving the bones

Olson credited Carlson West Povondra Architects, the Omaha firm, with guiding the historic details — the "little nuances," as he put it, that come with a building that predates the automobile. Ideal Construction of Elkhorn handled the build. The structure went up in 1897, two years after an April 1895 fire destroyed ten buildings on Elkhorn's Main Street, which makes it one of the oldest commercial buildings left in the historic district.

The result is two fully separate restaurants under one roof, each with what Olson called a world-class kitchen. The main floor is La Vita Nuova. Upstairs, a fine-dining room built around a chef's tasting menu is targeted for mid-November. Olson kept the name under wraps Thursday but promised the plans "will be newsworthy."
The project took longer than the May opening date announced last December — the price of doing a 129-year-old building carefully — and La Vita Nuova quietly began service in early October before Thursday's grand opening.
The team
Olson introduced the two people he called imperative to the project's success. In the kitchen is chef Ben Maides, best known as chef and co-owner of Au Courant Regional Kitchen in Benson, which has been a fixture on Omaha's best-restaurant lists since it opened in 2016. Running the front of house is general manager Sara Wallace.
Olson said the dining experience at La Vita Nuova is unique to Omaha, and he was careful to spread the credit: to the Main Street merchants who turned out, to the architects and builders, and to the guests who had already filled the dining room in the first two weeks.
What's on the table

The food is Northern Italian in inspiration and handmade in practice. The anchor is the pizza program: an organic sourdough leavened with a heritage-grain starter from Niobrara Grain & Milling, built on 00 flour, fermented for more than 72 hours and baked in a wood-fired oven. Six pies run $19 to $21 — a margherita-style La Vita, a Calabrian-sausage Della Casa, a mushroom-and-parmesan-cream Mercato "from the farm," a bolognese, a spicy vodka with pancetta and stracciatella, and a Calabrese with spicy salami. A gluten-free crust is available, and every pie comes with crust dippers that include a local Calabrian honey.
The menu follows the traditional Italian progression from there: aperitivo, crudi ("Italian sashimi" — Beau Soleil oysters, tuna carpaccio, wagyu carne cruda), antipasti, salads, primi and secondi. House pastas include gnocchi alla pomodoro, a lasagna alla babbo with parmigiano espuma, bucatini with rock shrimp and a tagliatelle amatriciana made with house-cured guanciale and a farm egg, at $25 to $27. Secondi top out at a 14-ounce wagyu New York strip for $44; a half chicken cacciatore, pork chop alla parmigiana and pan-roasted trout run $27 to $31.
The bar leans into the aperitivo ritual with a Nuova Spritz built on a choice of house-made citrus liqueurs — limoncello, limettacello, arancello or pompelmocello — and a non-alcoholic version made with sparkling wine and a house citrus cordial. The wine list, as you'd expect from the Main Street Cellar owners, is curated rather than long.
The sourcing goes further than most new metro restaurants: the team practices sustainable agriculture on its own farm, led by "Magpie" Magnuson, and buys from small farmers and purveyors across the region — which is why the menu reads "farm greens," "farm herbs" and "farm egg."
The neighbors weigh in
The crowd moved to La Vita Nuova's patio after the ceremony, and the reviews were already in. Brendan Smyth, a videographer at 316 Strategy Group who recently visited Italy and who recently moved in directly across Main Street from the restaurant, had tested the margherita against the real thing.
"I ate pizza all over Italy a few months ago, and the margherita here is on par with what I had there," Smyth said. "Elkhorn has something special in its backyard." ~ Brendan Smyth
What it means for Main Street
Omaha City Council member Brinker Harding, whose District 6 includes Elkhorn, said he has already eaten at La Vita Nuova twice. "Downtown Elkhorn is an important node that is special to Omaha," Harding said. "Not everyone knows about downtown Elkhorn yet." He praised the activity among the district's merchants and said Main Street in Olde Towne Elkhorn "is special, and we want to keep it that way."
Liz Kerrigan, senior vice president of member and investor relations at the Greater Omaha Chamber, congratulated Olson, Maides and Wallace and said Olson "is doing great things for Omaha." Omaha is known for great restaurants, she said, and the room opening upstairs next month "is going to set the bar."
The business case is visible from the sidewalk. Elkhorn — founded in 1865, incorporated in 1886 and annexed by Omaha in the 2000s — has built its historic core on a short strip of locally owned anchors: Main Street Cellar, Uptown Java, Main Street Studios and Gallery and a handful of restaurants. A three-year hole at the center of that strip was obvious to anyone walking it. Filling it with two kitchens, a full bar and lunch and dinner service puts foot traffic back on the block, and the tasting-menu room upstairs will be a first for the district.
The restaurant is already hiring, and its About page sets the tone for what the Olsons are after: guests welcomed like family, and meals that turn into traditions.
If you go
La Vita Nuova, 2620 N. Main St., Elkhorn. 402-942-6740. Reservations through Resy. Hours: Sunday–Thursday 11 a.m.–9 p.m., Friday–Saturday 11 a.m.–10 p.m. Follow @lavitanuova.elkhorn on Instagram and Facebook. And be sure to let us know what you think of La Vita Nuova!




