Omaha’s Donut Delights: Unveiling the Local Favorites Through Polls and Personal Experiences

The Omaha donut scene is a testament to the city’s rich culinary diversity and its deep-rooted love for this humble yet delightful pastry. A recent online poll sheds light on the preferences of Omaha’s residents, revealing a community deeply passionate about their local donut shops. Each of these establishments offers more than just donuts; they offer a slice of Omaha’s heart and history.

Let’s dive into the sweetness and explore the top three donut shops in Omaha, guided by public opinion and a sprinkle of personal touch.

Square Donut – The #1 Best Donut in Omaha

15825 W. Maple Rd., Omaha, NE

a pan of pink square donuts

Topping the poll with 24% of the votes, Square Donut is not just a bakery but a local landmark. Elizabeth Pooley’s unique square-shaped treats have become a symbol of artisanal quality and creativity. Their maple bacon donut is a standout, blending the traditional with the innovative, making Square Donut not just a shop but an experience.

Image Credit: Omaha Food Magazine

LaMars Donuts – #2 A Close Second

17202 Audrey St, Omaha, NE and 17676 Welch Plz, Omaha, NE

a glass case full of circular donuts

Securing 18% of the votes, LaMars Donuts stands out for its vast selection of over 70 rotating flavors. This beloved shop caters to all tastes and preferences, making it a staple in the Omaha donut community for its variety and quality.

Image Credit: LaMars Donuts

Olsen’s Bake Shop –  #3 A Time-Honored Choice

1708 S 10th St, Omaha, NE

With 17% of the votes, Olsen’s Bake Shop is a cherished part of Omaha’s donut landscape. Stepping into Olsen’s is like taking a step back in time, where traditional baking methods and family recipes create unforgettable flavors. Known for its old-world charm and delicious kolaches, Olsen’s is a must-visit for both locals and visitors.

a yellow sign hanging off the side of a building and it says Olsen's Bake Shop

Sugared Ledge Bakery – The Rising Star

920 N 204th Ave, Elkhorn, NE and 110 N 243rd St, Waterloo, NE

a glazed donut frosted with chocolate icing and drizzled with peanut butter

Though newer to the scene, Sugared Ledge Bakery is quickly gaining popularity and creating raving fans throughout the Omaha metro area. Backed by the innovative Lucky Eleven Hospitality Group, this bakery offers custom and themed donuts that are becoming a hit among locals looking for something unique and personalized. One thing is for sure, they definitely have some of Omaha’s best donuts.

Image Credit: Sugared Ledge

Sunrize Donuts – The Family Gem

17676 Welch Plaza, Suite 7

a box of donuts

Capturing 7% of the votes, Sunrize Donuts, run by the Kinman family, offers a personal touch with their homemade donuts. Specializing in old-fashioned donuts made with in-shop ingredients, this shop is a testament to the love and care that goes into traditional donut-making.

Pettit’s Pastry – A Local Staple Since 1954

502 N. 16th St., Downtown Omaha and 311 N. 114th St., West Omaha

a glass case full of donuts

Pettit’s Pastry, a name synonymous with quality since 1954, continues to serve up classic frosted cake donuts and simple glazed favorites. Its location near parade routes makes it a convenient and popular choice for a sweet treat during Omaha’s many festivities.

Best Donuts in Omaha

a tray of caked donuts with vanilla and blueberry icing

In Omaha, donuts are more than just a morning treat; they are a symbol of community, tradition, and culinary pride. This journey through the city’s most loved donut shops, as voted by the locals, showcases the diverse and rich flavors that Omaha has to offer. From Square Donut’s innovative approach to Olsen’s timeless recipes to Sugared Ledge’s craft donuts, each shop has its own story to tell, one delicious bite at a time.

Who has Omaha’s best donuts? You be the judge and let us know!

Image Credit: Sugared Ledge

———————————————————–

Learn more about Omaha’s Best New Restaurants.